Five minutes of CO2 tables a day adds up to 35 minutes a week. In people new to breath holds, a recent review concluded that hold training does not seem to improve hemoglobin or aerobic performance.
Many breath-hold guides focus on CO2 tolerance and red blood cells, then link both to endurance. The research behind each is thinner than the headline, and some of it points the other way.
If you've got a streak going on a hold-table app and you're hoping your 5K pace follows, the evidence is mixed. The trials behind it were small.
Does Hypoxic Training Build Endurance or Just Tolerance?
In beginners, nobody has shown that hold training builds endurance. A 6-week trial of static holds in novices found no change in hemoglobin mass, peak VO2 or 3 km time trial. Two-week trials found no improvement in hemoglobin concentration or time to exhaustion, though an 8-week trial in novices found a small rise in hemoglobin concentration. The Experimental Physiology review says the low-oxygen dose in novices was likely too small to trigger a strong red-blood-cell response.
The EPO findings fit that idea. The main review found that only long, intense protocols in people skilled at holds raised EPO. That's the hormone that tells the body to make red blood cells. The rise was brief and didn't turn into more hemoglobin over time.
Oxygen in novices dipped to about 82 to 96 percent. In trained freedivers it fell to about 73 to 76 percent. A beginner's session may simply be too mild to trigger much.
Then there's the spleen. A set of maximal holds raises hemoglobin 2 to 5 percent on average. The spleen likely releases red blood cells, though how much is debated. Most of these studies were in small groups of trained men.
The bump is brief, and in most trials it didn't improve time-trial performance.
What CO2 Tolerance Training Can Cost You
CO2 tolerance training sounds like pure upside: less panic, longer holds. But the same review describes a debated warning that a dulled breathing response to CO2 could lower aerobic capacity. It came from studies of breath-hold divers. In them, a lowered CO2 response held back breathing at every exercise intensity and shifted energy supply toward anaerobic. Nobody has shown this in women or recreational trainees, so it's a question, not a finding.
The form with the best signal is different. End-expiratory holds in repeated sprints (holds after breathing out) may improve repeated-sprint ability, according to small trials, though the mechanisms are unclear. Trials used as few as six sessions, and 3- to 4-week blocks are typically recommended. The athletes were runners, cyclists, swimmers and team-sport players.
That's a repeated-sprint result. It says little about whether holds raise VO2 max, since some of those studies found no change in peak VO2.
None of this applies to slow, relaxed breathing. That's a different practice, and what breathwork is and how it works separates the two kinds. If aerobic capacity is the goal, zone 2 cardio has its own caveats about who was tested.


